
Great guys love their mothers. They adore them, cherish them, and appreciate them.
This is a fabulous thing. Guys who have great relationships with their mothers often make for fabulous husbands!
There are however those guys who are so attached to their mothers that they are unable to have a normal, mature emotionally healthy relationship with a woman.
What is going on?
Why do some men seem unable to move from a dependent boy to a grown adult? Why are some men, "Mama's boys"?
In healthy homes, children grow up feeling unconditionally loved. They know their parents love and care for them. When these children make mistakes, they may feel their parents are disappointed but they do not feel the love of their parents is in jeopardy.
In some homes, a boy may grow up feeling his mother's approval and love is very conditional. These boys don't ever feel really loved and accepted, and constantly and continually try to gain this love. These boys often work hard trying to please their demanding mothers, doing everything they can to be a "good boy" so their mothers will love them.
While obviously most children want to please their parents, the unhealthiness comes in when love is only given when a child is pleasing; when parental love and care are dependent on a child's "appropriate behavior", and when a mother's demands are about her needs being satisfied.
In the case of "Mama's boys", boys grow up, never feeling true mother's love, yet continually striving for it. In order to feel their mother's love, they must continually cater to her, please her, and above all, never cross her or show disagreement or disobedience.
Now if a guy is single, this may be an unhealthy dynamic but it doesn't necessarily create huge problems. The problems often arise when a "Mama's boy" wants to have a mature relationship. His need to please his controlling and unaccepted mother may conflict with a healthy, mature relationship.
Which brings us to the core of the problem.
A man who was raised by a controlling and unaccepting mother will most likely never receive the unconditional love he seeks from her. As difficult as this is to accept it is the reality. He may spend his life trying to please her, cater to her, and fulfill her every demand and still, his dream of acceptance from his mother will elude him.
For a "Mama's boy" to have a mature and healthy loving relationship with a woman, he needs to accept the fact that his mother most likely will not change, and he needs to set new boundaries.
For a marriage to be successful and respectful, both partners must put the needs of their relationship and each other over the futile attempt to please a demanding and controlling parent.
A relationship will not survive if a man is more concerned with pleasing his domineering mother than he is nourishing his relationship and supporting his wife.
This doesn't mean a man should not respect and honor his mother. Of course as adult children we want to care for our parents and loved ones. It does mean that, as we become adults our relationships change, grow, and mature.
Mother's who continually demand a grown son's unending and exclusive devotion, will continue to do so until the son realizes the unhealthiness of the relationship and clearly decides to create a mutually respectful one.
It is not always easy. In fact, letting go of the dream for unconditional love from a mother is not easy for those sons who have spent a lifetime trying to gain approval. Yet, it is necessary for a normal healthy long-term intimate relationship.




21 thoughts and insights:
I disagree with the importance you place on a man's relationship with his Mother in enabling him to form suitable relationships with Women. For my own part I am virtually estranged from my wicked Mother but my Wife and her Parents adore me. I think this is because a Man's attitude towards Women is formed during adolescence around
his Father's attitude and behaviour towards Women. I was fortunate in having a wonderful Father and I hope that I can one day be the same to my children.
Its just that boys take their cues for behaviour towards Women from the Alpha Male (usually the Father) and a Mother's input at this stage in development becomes more nurture and domestic.
Hi Wolfie... ahhh you make a great point.
There are certainly great men with unkind, hurtful, and cruel mothers; men who do not think highly of these women.
Absolutely.
And there are great men whose fathers are not-so-great as well.
Sometimes men with horrible fathers learn to be great men, and sometimes men with horrible mothers learn to be great men as well.
Thanks for your thoughts and imput!
Jennifer
Hi Jennifer,
I had to go through my late teens and early adulthood without guidance from either of my great parents. Today is the anniverary of my mother's death when I was 16. Many times I could have saved confusion and sometimes heartache, had I had a parent to talk with during those years.
I've come to accept a professional, other things being equal, that a young person gains many of the subtle understandings about man-woman relationships from the parent of the opposite sex.
Having said that, I think your recognition that the man has to shift his focus to his new family is dead on. I've seen many shipwrecks in my office when he could not detach from mom.
(I have also seen many wrecks where the woman is the one who could not detach.)
To Wolfie I would add this: None of us comes from a perfect family and it sounds like you have sought guidance in the right places and made excellent choices. But beware of anyone putting you on a pedestal (adore?). If that is happening, and I hope it's not what you meant, it's a setup for a fall from grace.
Neill
Hi Neill...
Thanks for your always thoughtful insights! I truly appreciate your expertise!
I was trying to make the point that it is great for men to love their mothers, and that the problems come in when the mother/son relationships does not allow for a healthy partnership but I don't think I was too clear. :-(
My heart goes out to you as you remember the death of your mother. I read your post about the death of your parents with tears running down my face!
You have had more sorrow than should be allowed for one life... and with this, you are such an example of grace, compassion, and wisdom.
I deeply appreciate your gifts to our world!
Blessings of peace to you,
Jen
Dearest Jennifer,
My deepest gratitude!
I can't begin to tell you the mind games my mother-in-law plays on my hubby, such manipulation and the poor fellow is torn but he's like a drug addict who will never get better if he doesn't recognize there's a problem and want to change. He is blinded...feels that telling her "no" would be betrayal.
Saddens me but I've decided that I cannot wait forever for him to grow up or for her to pass.
Much love!!!!!
Hi Sweetie,
Ahhh sounds like things are pretty difficult!
You are exactly right when you suggest no one will change unless they realize there is a problem and are willing to change, (or unless something drastic happens... like death)!
The reality is, once a guy gets married, mom needs to be supportive of his relationship with his wife... mom's "needs" are secondary!
I have a family member with a similar situation... in this case it is the MIL who is just unbelievably manipulative, and out-of-control demanding!
Doesn't make for a healthy relationship that is for sure!
Keep me posted dear... I'm sure thinking about you!
Lots of love,
Jen
Thank you for your insightful posting! I just recently ended a nearly 5 year relationship when I slowly saw the attachment to mama of my significant other grow. While the attachment grew, so did our problems. His mother was passive aggressive and manipulative. It got to a point where he would be calling his mother in the middle of dinner at a fine restaurant!!!!
I guess I was not the kind of “wife” she wanted for her son. Yet I wonder if there will be anyone for her taste. Perhaps because I always felt a wife should come first and – believe it or not we actually argued about this.
It becomes a major lesson for people who go through this. A solid relationship has its own challenges, but I now realize that in one such as mine I was the one trying to set up a foundation and someone else kept stopping it. It’s not really worth it to have to fight with someone on things that should really be understood. On the upside, I truly feel like I dodged a bullet :)
Hi Anon...
Thanks for sharing your experience!
The thing is... lots of times the "Mama's boys" do not think ANY woman is the right one for their sons.
It is not the person but the fact that mom is not #1 in her son's life.
Sounds like you have made some really good choices... as you state, a great relationship does not happen unless the foundation is good!
Nice to have you here!
:-)
Jennifer
still waiting for the article about women and their fathers
Hi Anon..
Thanks for asking! :-)
Actually, I have a little disclaimer in the sidebar that states many of the ideas in my posts apply equally to women.
Because this is a blog intended to help women find great men I'm focusing on topics that are specific to this purpose.
Having said this... men and women both need to put their marriage and partners first! :-)
Wishing you a great day!
Jennifer
Hi Jenifer,
I feel that I am a mamas boy, not like it used to be as I have grown up and matured a lot over the past few years, however my mother is getting worse and worse.
Her and my amazing gf are always fighting and my mum is always making my gf upset. My mum has also been working on my father since I have moved 500 miles away.
I dont know what to do, I find it difficult to say no to her as she then emotionally blackmails me and makes me feel bad.
My mother does not like the fact that I am growing up and that my gf is the most important thing to me. My mother never sees she is doing anything wrong and will never applogise about making my gf upset.
My mum has also had a drink problem for a few years now and this has also put strain on my relationship with my gf, coz she does things when she is drunk and does not remember them.
I am reaching the end of my tether, but still I cant seem to turn my back on my mother and family, i just want to run away with my gf and forget about it all, any advice!
Hi Anon,
You sound like a great guy who is aware of the various dynamics going on... your girlfriend is lucky because a lot of guys don't see the problems! :-)
Having a controlling mother can be a really difficult thing for guys stuck with trying to please them while having a love relationship.
The best "advice" I can give you is to set some boundaries. Decide what is or is not appropriate and then hold to your position.
For example, you may decide that if your mother speaks badly of your girlfriend, that is not acceptable and you will not engage in a discussion with her if she can not be respectful. Then, the minute she starts complaining about your girlfriend, you hold to your decision and disengage, or leave.
At first your mother will be even more nasty but in time, when she realizes you are clear in what you will or will not tolerate, her behavior will change.
Keep up the good communication with your girlfriend, stay true to her, let her know how much you care...
I think you will work it out!
Best of luck... keep me posted K?
Jennifer
Jennifer, help!!
This blog is just what I was looking for- a place to give me solid advice on relationship.
I have a boyfriend of 8 months. We love each other very much and want to get married eventually.
His mother is a nice, good person who does a lot for the community. BUT- even though she's a great person, she can be needy and feels the need to control most aspects of his life.
He has two sisters who are crippled so he has to live at home to take care of them. Also, one of his sisters has a small child who is mentally ill.
Although I love my bf's family, I am worried that if we ever get married he won't be able to put me first.
I don't want to end up divorced!!!
I know his family situation is not his fault but couldn't he move out and just go over there to take care of them? His mother is pretty well off. Couldn't she hire someone as a caretaker?
He says that he is family and family has to take care of family.
He also takes care of his granpa.
His mother decides whether or not he "can go out" or if she "needs him" at home. She likes me but I'm worried that I will always be second to her. She's always calling me to find out where he is or to ask me to "make him" do something, like go talk to a boss or something.
It's harder because he works near to where she works so she's always around and he says he can never move to another city because of his family.
Should I break up with him?? I really really want to make this work. I love him so much.
Hi Anonymous...
I'm sorry I missed your post until now...
It sure sounds like a challenging situation for you and for your boyfriend.
You do seem like you are very aware of the difficulties that may lie ahead which is a very good thing... you are not going into the relationship blindly! :-) Good for you!
There are many relationships that are complicated by extended family situations... for sure. Some fine ways to manage well and are quite successful. These couples have set clear boundaries, defined what is and is not acceptable, and have committed to putting their relationship first.
There are others who are less successful.
My suggestion is to be very clear on what is acceptable to you, and to your boyfriend. Decide what is or is not OK.
Ask yourself the tough questions. Will you always be way down the list of priorities? Are you willing to accomodate his extra responsibilities? Can you both agree on what the relationship will look like in the future?
Be honest with yourself and each other!
Take your time, and keep up the great work!
Best of luck to you...
Jen
thanks so much! that was really good advice!
Hi, i recently found out that the mother of the guy that im seeing feeds him, like his a little boy!! That was so fricky that i really dont wanna see him again!!!
Hi, my name is Lulu Taylor and I've just recently written a novel, called: Stop the Mama's Boys... I, too, had been involved in the love triangle of a Mama's Boy. Unfortunately, it is a long and winding road filled with a lot of heartache for the woman involved in this type of relationship. However, I've seen relationships overcome this obstacle where the Mama's Boy evolved and was able to sustain a healthy relationship with another woman, but it takes a LOT of work and patience to break this strong psychological bond...and I've seen many, including mine, end in despair and grief. The state of the "Mama's Boy" has been an issue that has been around for many years, and unfortunately becoming more of a presence in the state of the world as we know it today. Why? We need to examine this dilemma from all angles and get to the root of the problem to heal. Why do some mothers develop this type of relationship with their sons and others do not? Through my research, I have found many patterns in these types of mothers. I have dedicated an entire business to discussing this topic as I think it's truly vital that we share our stories and resolve these issues. I do not believe that any mother, whether she enters motherhood voluntarily or unvoluntarily, purposefully intends on becoming an MB mother. Let's talk about this some more!
I am married to a mama's boy she makes him feel awful about himself guilty if he cannot run over there when she needs him. She thinks my husband is her husband me,me,me,me, it's sick a mother can do this to her son soooooo unhealthy. not sure what todo
Hi Anonymous... yes I agree, thoes types of relationships you describe are not healthy in the least!
What to do?
Well, this is a difficult question as you know.
Bascially, you can learn to live with it, you can do your best to help your hubby understand who he is married to, or you could leave the relationsip.
I hold to the idea that most marriages can be healthy and happy if both partners are wiling to invest in the relationship, so I think there is the possibility for a great marriage for you.
However, if your husband is not willing to work on the relationship and remember to whom he is married, it may be that you are left with living with it or leaving.
I know it is difficult... my heart goes out to you!
Lots of love,
Jennifer
I fear I am in a relationship with a "mama's boy". It is not neccessarily that he is holding onto her, but she is holding onto him for dear life(single mom), and I just don't know what to do. She treats him like he is 5 (he is 27) and he does not draw boundaries. I find it wierd that she sends him emails that says, "just thinking about you" and leaves him notes with hearts on it. Do you? Although she will respect his space when he asks for it, whenever she does have the opportunity, she takes advantage of the situation and dominates it, and it feels like a bulldozer running me over. I have expressed these feelings to him, and although he assures me that this will change, i fear that this problem will never go away because crazy mothers do not change. I love him, but I may have to leave him because I do not want to have to have space in my partner's life. suggestions?
Hi Jennifer,
I have a bf who is much much younger than me. I am 36 and he is 25. But this is not a problem to us although sometimes it is for me coz I am afraid that he will find another woman since he is still young. But he assured me that he will never do that. THe main problem is that he is so attach to his mother and 2 brothers. He is easily influenced by his mother and brothers. THe mother does not like me at all because I am miles away from him and they are thinking that I am only using him. Every time that we plan something to do, he will still have to consult it to his family and if they dont like it. It will not happen anymore because they said it so. We are planning for our future and he cant moved out of the house because he has to help her brother pay all the mortgages and he does not want to abandon his brother. I feel like he will never get out of his shell and try to experiment something new in his life. I love him so much and willing to be with him but I do not know if how long I can live like this. I do not know if I can live a life like this that he is easily influence by his family. I want a marriage that will last and not only will last for a year. Do I have to help him figure out what he wants in his life or do i have to leave him? Honestly I do not know what to do coz I love him so much. Please help.......
Post a Comment